Naturediet Salmon & White Fish vs Simpsons Premium Four Bird Casserole with Organic Vegetables
How the two products stack up on rating, ingredients and analysis.
Visit Naturediet · Visit Simpsons Premium
Both are rated at essentially the same level: Naturediet Salmon & White Fish scores 85 and Simpsons Premium Four Bird Casserole with Organic Vegetables scores 85 out of 100.
| Metric | Naturediet Salmon & White Fish | Simpsons Premium Four Bird Casserole with Organic Vegetables |
|---|---|---|
| Product and intended use | ||
| Brand | Naturediet | Simpsons Premium |
| Type | Wet Pate | Wet Chunks |
| Kind / completeness | complete | complete |
| Lifestage | Adult | All lifestages |
| Score | ||
| Rating (Recipe) | 85Good | 85Good |
| Recipe and label | ||
| Poor ingredients | 0 | 0 |
| Clear label | yes | yes |
| Declared quantities | Salmon 64.0%, White Fish 28.0%, Water 8.0% (0% undeclared) | Goose 60.0%, Duck 15.0%, Chicken 15.0%, Turkey 15.0% (0% undeclared) |
| First ingredient | Salmon · meat good | Goose · meat good |
| Ingredient count | 3 | 9 |
| Additives | 5 nutritional | 1 nutritional |
| Badges | CompleteHigh meatClear labelFull label | CompleteHigh meatClear labelFull label |
| Declared nutrition | ||
| Protein (as fed) | 12% | 10.80% |
| Fat (as fed) | 10.50% | 5.20% |
| Fibre (as fed) | 2% | 0.50% |
| Ash (as fed) | 3% | 2.50% |
| Moisture (as fed) | 68% | 80% |
| Energy | - | - |
| Dry-matter estimates | ||
| Meat share (dry matter) | 98% | 100% |
| Recall history | ||
| Recall history | None recorded in our database | None recorded in our database |
Product and intended use
Brand
Type
Kind / completeness
Lifestage
Score
Rating (Recipe)
Recipe and label
Poor ingredients
Clear label
Declared quantities
First ingredient
Ingredient count
Additives
Badges
Declared nutrition
Protein (as fed)
Fat (as fed)
Fibre (as fed)
Ash (as fed)
Moisture (as fed)
Dry-matter estimates
Meat share (dry matter)
Recall history
Recall history
Lifestage comes from the manufacturer's own labelling. Dry-matter figures are estimates from the published label; recall history is presentation-only and never affects the score.
Shared ingredients
The two recipes share 0 matched ingredients. Tier badges show each ingredient's glossary grade.
Only in Naturediet Salmon & White Fish
Salmon goodWhite Fish goodWaterOnly in Simpsons Premium Four Bird Casserole with Organic Vegetables
Goose goodDuck mediumChicken mediumTurkey mediumPotatoes mediumCarrots goodPumpkin goodSpinach goodVitamins and minerals mediumIf neither suits
Instead of Naturediet Salmon & White Fish
Higher rated, same format
Instead of Simpsons Premium Four Bird Casserole with Organic Vegetables
Higher rated, same format
Frequently asked questions
Which has the higher rating, Naturediet Salmon & White Fish or Simpsons Premium Four Bird Casserole with Organic Vegetables?
They are rated at essentially the same level: 85 and 85 out of 100. A gap this small is within the tolerance of the scoring model.
How are these ratings calculated?
Open Dog Food parses each published ingredient list, estimates missing quantities, converts every ingredient to its dry-matter share and scores the recipe from 1 to 100. The full method is on the methodology page.